About Me

Name: Michael
Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Zinn

For some reason I find myself blogging overtime on the weekends. Seeing as my work doesn't really require me to go anywhere, it's not like I'm not around the computer enough to blog. Hmmm...

Earlier this week, Dennis Prager posted an article, which is available on Townhall.com, which documented a discussion he had with the legendary Leftist, Howard Zinn. Zinn is author of The People's History of the United States, which I have somewhere in the house. Their dialogue was very interesting:

HZ: That's true that the great majority of Indians died of disease in the 17th century when the Europeans first came here. But after that -- after the American Revolution -- when the colonists expanded from the thin band of colonies along the Atlantic and expanded westward, at that point we began to annihilate the Indian tribes. We committed massacres all over the country . . . .

DP: What percentage of the Indians do you believe we massacred, as opposed to diseases ravaged?

HZ: Oh, well it might have been 10 percent.

DP: But 10 percent is very different from the generalization of "we annihilated the Indians."

HZ: Oh, well 10 percent is a huge number of Indians, that is. So it's pointless I think to argue about whether disease . . . or deliberate attacks killed more Indians . . . .

DP: No, but 10 percent is very different from what the general statement of "annihilate" tends to indicate. That's all I am saying.

HZ: Okay.


Prager's interview with Zinn is also available as a podcast.

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive